A bi-weekly challenge from Andre Mirabelli & Opturo

If you use “Purchases in the Basis Dietz”, how do you approach the following scenario?
The cash in a portfolio starts the day with a small gain and then the portfolio uses all of the starting cash and half of that small cash gain (“sells cash”) to purchase a non-cash instrument. Thus, nothing ever goes short.


If, as many suggest, one uses a “purchases at open and sales at close” Dietz calculation for the trade-inclusive return of a component of a portfolio on a single day, in order to keep non-cash returns reasonable in the presence of large sales, how should one calculate the weight and return of cash so that weights still sum to one and the returns of all holdings roll up appropriately to the portfolio return, without having an actual gain in cash being described by an unreasonably large negative cash return? To avoid this problem, would it be OK if the returns of un-traded holdings change just because other items in the portfolio are traded?

A bi-weekly challenge from Andre Mirabelli & Opturo

Related news

The Structure And Visualization Of Performance Attribution

The Journal of Performance Measurement--Andre Mirabelli, Ph.D.--This paper presents a simply additive, yet formally exact, approach to multi-period performance attribution. It also introduces a visual representation, which makes this new approach and its relationship to prior approaches intuitively clear.
Read more

How ODIN’s Application Builder accelerates data insights for asset managers

Data teams are constantly looking for ways to accelerate insights without sacrificing precision or control. Enter ODIN's Application Builder—a no-code/low-code solution that empowers business users and developers alike to configure, automate, and scale complex data workflows in minutes—not months. One of our clients, a global asset manager, leveraged Application Builder to streamline daily portfolio analytics.…
Read more

A bi-weekly challenge from Andre Mirabelli & Opturo

How does an attribution modeler address the following challenge?Karnosky and Singer provided an ex post decision attribution methodology that attributed active returns to currency decisions in an investment process that could actually be carried out. Are there ever valid reasons, in an ex post decision attribution process, for attributing active returns to currency-related properties that…